• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to McCall's Tavern

McCall's Tavern, located at 997 Alverez Ave in Lady Lake, FL, offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Known for its impressive menu, the tavern delights diners with hearty dishes like their standout chicken dinner and shepherd's pie, both praised for their homemade flavors. Guests enjoy attentive service, with highlights including a friendly staff and a vibrant community vibe, often complemented by live music and entertainment events. Tucked away next to a bowling alley, McCall's Tavern creates a unique dining experience, perfect for casual explorers looking to unwind with good food and great company.

McCall's Tavern: Reviews & Ratings

Casual Explorer
Casual Explorer

OK, this restaurant lured me in with a free birthday dinner resulting in a future customer. The chicken dinner was absolutely fantastic. My wife had a shepherd's pie which was very good. We both agreed the food tasted like homemade and it was probably the best meal we have had since moving here. There is a bowling alley attached which will try at a later date. Thank you and see you again soon.

Melisa at Plains Cottage
Melisa at Plains Cottage

First time here and as a former restaurant critic, I am pleasantly surprised! Great service by Emalee, our server, and the food portions and quality was very good. It’s connected to the bowling alley which we didn’t know either. The Manager was sweet too and loved that we are both originally from WV.

Ashlee Anderson
Ashlee Anderson

Delightful. First time here. Had a Reuben with garlic Parmesan fries, DELICIOUS Fries were a little greasy, but the flavor outweighed the grease. Great service. Attached to a bowling alley, but you would never know it.

Howard Crostic
Howard Crostic

Hey. I'm giving this place 5 stars based on tonight. They had the best country band I've heard in a long time. Also had a great waitress, the food was good and drinks were kept full. Place was full and we shared a table with a very nice couple. 5 star all the way. OK, it's Monday 10 23 2023. Another review popped up. It's open mic by Luke. Place it packed. Entertainment is great. Not posting this to increase business here, don't want to loose my seat next Mon.

Chuck Wiggy
Chuck Wiggy

We had great music, food, drink & service. Definitely will return

Kyle Cyr
Kyle Cyr

A Great Spot with an Even Better Patio Vibe Stopped by with some friends for lunch during the downtown art festival, and the patio atmosphere was perfect—such a great place to relax and soak in the energy of the event. Even though the staff seemed a bit short-handed and service was a little slow, our server handled it all with a smile and was genuinely helpful and kind. The food more than made up for the wait—absolutely delicious! Overall, a really enjoyable experience. I'd definitely come back, especially during downtown events.

Kay Kings
Kay Kings

I would give it a 5 but it was way too busy the day we visited! Drinks were good and chilled. Bathrooms were clean and staff were all polite and friendly too. They communicated in a timely manner and made sure we were taken care of! We would love to go back when they are less busy at different day and time of the week.

Kenny Miller
Kenny Miller

Great fried shrimp dinner and awesome bartenders. 10/10/23. What an awesome time we had. We had the fresh fried chicken dinner and it was just what the heart needed. All the fried goodness. The waitress "Erica" was friendly and attentive. I would just go back there to have her be our waitress again. Thanks.

Location

  • McCall's Tavern
    997 Alverez Ave, Lady Lake, FL 32159, United States Hotline: +1 352-750-9441

Welcome to McCall's Tavern, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lady Lake, Florida. Located at 997 Alverez Ave, this inviting establishment is more than just a place to grab a bite; it is a culinary experience crafted for food lovers and casual diners alike. With a reputation for comfort food that tastes like it was lovingly prepared at home, McCall's Tavern quickly captivates its guests with a warm atmosphere and a delightful menu.

Patrons rave about their dishes, with highlights including a fantastic chicken dinner and a flavorful shepherd's pie that have left diners truly satisfied. One delightful review from a happy birthday celebrant noted that their meal was perhaps the best they've had since moving to the area. Who can resist such an enticing testimonial?

Beyond the food, McCall's Tavern boasts an engaging experience, featuring live music that sets the tone for a lively evening. Customers have shared their enthusiasm over the talented country bands and open mic nights that enhance their dining experience. The ambiance is further enriched by the tavern's connection to a bowling alley, providing a unique blend of dining and entertainment that keeps guests returning for more.

Service at McCall's Tavern has repeatedly received high praise, with servers like Emalee leaving a lasting impression on first-time visitors. The commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in the attentiveness of the staff and the welcoming vibe of the space.

If you’re looking for a place that combines delicious, hearty meals with good company and entertainment, McCall's Tavern should be at the top of your list. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply in search of a satisfying dinner, this tavern promises an experience you'll want to repeat. Come join the myriad of happy diners who have discovered the treasure that is McCall's Tavern—you might just find your new favorite restaurant!